(View this PageEdit this PageUploads to this PageHistory of this PageHomeRecent ChangesSearch the SwikiHelp Guide)

Closing Discussion Notes

the following are the notes from our final civic studio discussion along with questions posed and comments from our visitors.

  • the quirks of the neighbourhood change the familiar into something specific to the area.
  • Objectification of a place can happen when you don't live there ie.tourism
  • People find it hard to think of impermanence, everything is presumed to be concrete and forever.
HAVE WE TAPPED INTO THE COMMUNITY?
WHERE IS THE COMMUNITY?
  • is it the people who live or work there?
WHO WANTS COMMUNITY AND WHY?
  • finding community and temporary space links to Kwon's criticism of temporary involvement.
WHAT WOULD BE THE IDEAL LEVEL OF COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT?
  • the detachment of studio work.
"the world we share is visual material,artists are visula material people".
  • unease created by voyeristic observation of community for our pleasure/interest.
  • we need to accept a changing definition of community from project to project.
  • a community can be common interests of shared ideals.
  • just thinking about community is important and valid.
  • there are many problems with definitive labels.

"we'll never know our impact (on the community) or hear all the conversations"

WHAT HAVE WE LEARNT FROM CRESTON?
  • that it has a unique character.
  • it seems to be built on nostalgia, trying to rebuild/return to its former glory.
  • could this impression have been created by starting with historical research?
  • revitalisation only happens when attempting to regain something lost.
WHEN WAS CRESTON'S HAYDAY?
WHAT CHANGES ARE THERE NOW?
  • not much pedestrian traffic.
  • a lack of people oriented business Eg,department stores.
  • creston used to be more cohesive,death of family owned business (big companies taking stores to the suburbs/strip malls)
"tight knit community is the least ammount of distance between where people live and where they work".
  • stilgoe talks about people moving to own property, a move towards private living/cars ect.
  • there is a breakdown of people knowing/making the effort to know each other.
  • routine Vs. change.

"community exists in moments, it is the chance interactions and engagements with people that equal community".
  • some people never engage.
  • one reason is the economic diversity (towne+club)
WHAT PART OF CRESTON DO YOU BELONG TO?
  • there is one than 1 neighbourhood.
  • the ways in which economics shape/force a community.
Eg if everyone worked close enough to walk everywhere/some people have to work way out of town.
WHAT DID THE NAME TOWNE CLUB MEAN TO THE OWNER?
  • (history of towne club soda)
  • a return to the old way of selling soda,not competing with big business.
  • the 'E' really does make it fancy.
  • there were 35 flavors of soda and 9 diet ones indicating the closeness of the business to the people.
  • it was bought straight from the factory, reusable bottles were returned.
  • problems caused by selling in supermarkets and not getting the bottles returned.
  • soda sold with nostalgia ("like olden days")a marketing ideal.
  • original label design nostalgic like 50's style.
IS ANYTHING NEW ANYMORE?
  • age old discussion about postmodernist reaction against modernism.
  • presenting of a new brands identity.
KWONTEXT
  • ideal of the artist as a citizen, removing the institution.
  • new ideas generated by inclusion of more people, the difference of civic studio over other studios.
  • ways to stop group work turing into an assignment/delegation.
  • the importance of a common interest/commitment.
  • we have the freedom to engage in fluid ideas without a top down structure.
  • were neil and jesse feeling pigeon holed by being in charge of all graffic design?

  • the general fear of not knowing what was going on was felt by many in the studio.
"that's the description of a cult, you dont know what it is but you're in it"
  • what if we had gotten into the goo earlier?
  • how it has affected us not having facilities.
  • the risk that was taken with a large class size.
  • the issues concerned with local and global. you have to live in the community to really know it, outsiders see differently.
  • people comming into the space activated the exhibition.
  • what roles did we play as cultural signifiers?
  • driving used to be fun, now everyone hurries and on the defensive.

Beth Lively's final comment "you seems to get it"

kate 5/1

-----------